{"_shards":{"failed":0,"skipped":0,"successful":3,"total":3},"hits":{"hits":[{"_id":"298011","_index":"publication","_score":12.1416445,"_source":{"abstracts":[{"abstract":"Nablus Muharebesi (The Battle of Megiddo), Birinci Dünya Savaşı sırasında, General Liman vonSanders komutasındaki Osmanlı orduları ile General Edmund Allenby komutasındaki Mısır SeferKuvveti’ne bağlı İngiliz birlikleri arasında yaşanan son büyük muharebedir. Bu muharebedeİngiliz (Britanya) ordusu karşısında Osmanlı ordusunun uğradığı hezimet, Osmanlı Devleti’ninFilistin’deki egemenliğini sona erdirmiş, Osmanlı muharip unsurlarının Halep’in kuzeyine kadargeri çekilerek Suriye’nin de elden çıkmasında belirleyici olmuştur. Mustafa Kemal Paşa da buönemli sonuçlara neden olan Nablus Muharebesi’ne, Yedinci Ordu Komutanı olarak katılmış vemuharebedeki yenilgiyi yaşamıştır. Bu bağlamda Türkiye’deki Atatürk karşıtı çevreler, yıllardır,Nablus yenilgisinin baş sorumlusunun Mustafa Kemal Paşa olduğuna yönelik bir yazım vesöylem geliştirmişlerdir. Aslında bu yazım ve söylemi geliştirenlerin dayandıkları referanskaynağı, Cevat Rifat Atilhan’ın 1950’de Büyük Doğu dergisinde, “Görünmeyen İnkılâp” başlıklıtefrikasında yazdıklarıdır. Bu çalışmada, Mustafa Kemal Paşa’ya yönelik ithamlar ve iddialarortaya konulmuş ve bunların gerçeklerle örtüşmediği, askeri literatürdeki bilgiler ve Atilhan’ın1918’de yazdıkları çerçevesinde ortaya konulmuştur.","id":569354,"keywords":null,"language":"TUR","title":"NABLUS MUHAREBESİ’NDE MUSTAFA KEMAL PAŞA: İTHAMLAR VE GERÇEKLER"},{"abstract":"The Battle of Nablus (Megiddo) is the last battle that occurred, during World War I, between the Ottoman armies under the command of the Yildirim Army Group led by General Liman von Sanders and the British forces (The Egyptian Expeditionary Force) led by General Edmund Allenby. Due to the serious defeat of the Ottoman army against the British army, the rule of the Ottoman Empire in Palestine ended with this battle. The military troops of the Ottoman State withdrew until the north of Aleppo which had a significant effect on the loss of Syria. Mustafa Kemal Pasha participated in this significant Battle of Nablus as the Commander of the Seventh Ottoman Army and suffered defeat in the battle. For years, anti-Atatürk groups in Turkey have argued, both orally and in writing that, Mustafa Kemal Pasha was mainly responsible for the defeat of Nablus. These arguments were primarily based on Cevat Rifat Atilhan’s article titled “Görünmeyen İnkilâp”, which was published in Büyük Doğu Magazine in 1950. In this research, the accusations and claims against Mustafa Kemal Pasha are presented and it is revealed, based on the information available in literature and the texts written by Atilhan in 1918 that; they do not conform to the facts, indeed.","id":377341,"keywords":null,"language":"ENG","title":"Mustafa Kemal Pasha in the Battle of Nablus: Accusations and Facts"}],"accessType":"OPEN","attachments":null,"authors":[{"authorId":927607,"duty":"AUTHOR","inPublicationName":"Nuri KARAKAŞ","institution":{"city":["İZMİR"],"code":["Mzk2NjI5"],"country":["Türkiye"],"fullTitle":["EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ \u003e EDEBİYAT FAKÜLTESİ \u003e TARİH BÖLÜMÜ"],"rootCode":["MzU1MDMy"],"rootTitle":["EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ"],"status":["KAMU"],"title":["TARİH BÖLÜMÜ"],"type":[""]},"institutionName":["Ege Üniversitesi, Edebiyat Fakültesi, Tarih Bölümü, İzmir, Türkiye"],"isVerified":false,"name":"Nuri Karakaş","orcid":"0000-0002-2359-8944","order":1,"relationId":868946,"userId":""}],"citedReferences":[{"authors":[{"id":725246,"name":"Mehmet Emin ELMACI"}],"docType":"PAPER","id":20669864,"journalCode":"706","sourceId":1264139,"year":"2024"}],"createdBy":"69f4100d-bf9c-4f80-a01d-938f66ae2716","databases":["SOCIAL"],"docType":"PAPER","doi":null,"downloadCount":20,"endDate":null,"endPage":"519","facetAuthorCity":["İZMİR"],"facetAuthorCountry":["Türkiye"],"facetAuthorInstitution":["EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ"],"firstIndexDate":"2019-05-27T00:00:00Z","id":298011,"indexDate":"2026-05-23T15:54:20.051789Z","indexedBy":"indexer","issue":{"id":45202,"isSpecial":false,"month":["12"],"number":"2","publishDate":"2018-07-01T00:00:00","volume":"33","year":"2018"},"journal":{"eissn":"0257-4152","id":"385","issn":"0257-4152","name":"Tarih İncelemeleri Dergisi"},"language":"TUR","orderCitationCount":1,"orderTitle":"NABLUSMUHAREBESİ’NDE MUSTAFA KEMAL PAŞA: İTHAMLAR VE GERÇEKLER","otherCitations":null,"pdf":"60ea57f8-9dc6-4d3a-b344-ecdefb5af7e2","projectGroup":null,"projectnumber":null,"publicationProduct":null,"publicationType":"COMPILATION","publicationYear":2018,"references":[{"authors":null,"context":"Genelkurmay ATASE Daire Başkanlığı Arşivi","id":1189609,"journalCode":"","order":1,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Akşam","id":1189716,"journalCode":"","order":2,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Âti (İleri)","id":1189645,"journalCode":"","order":3,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Hadisat","id":1189687,"journalCode":"","order":4,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"İkdam","id":1189580,"journalCode":"","order":5,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Minber","id":1189746,"journalCode":"","order":6,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Müstakil Gazete","id":1189610,"journalCode":"","order":7,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Sabah","id":1189717,"journalCode":"","order":8,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Son Telgraf","id":1189646,"journalCode":"","order":9,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Tasvir-i Efkâr","id":1189688,"journalCode":"","order":10,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Vakit","id":1189581,"journalCode":"","order":11,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Zaman","id":1189747,"journalCode":"","order":12,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Cevat Rifat, “Suriye Hezimet-i Faciası ve Sebepleri”, Tasvir-i Efkâr, 23 Teşrinisani\r\n1334 (23 Kasım 1918), Tefrika 1.","id":1189611,"journalCode":"","order":13,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Cevat Rifat, “Suriye Hezimet-i Faciası ve Sebepleri”, Tasvir-i Efkâr, 27 Teşrinisani\r\n1334 (27 Kasım 1918), Tefrika 2.","id":1189718,"journalCode":"","order":14,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Cevat Rifat, “Suriye Hezimet-i Faciası ve Sebepleri”, Tasvir-i Efkâr, 5 Kânunuevvel\r\n1334 (5 Aralık 1918), Tefrika 9.","id":1189647,"journalCode":"","order":15,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Cevat Rifat, “Şam’ın Sükûtu”, Âti, 26 Kânunuevvel 1334 (26 Aralık 1918).","id":1189689,"journalCode":"","order":16,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Cevat Rifat Atilhan, “Görünmeyen İnkılâp”, Büyük Doğu, Sayılar: 22, 25, 34, 35, 37,\r\n38, 39, 40, 41, 43.","id":1189582,"journalCode":"","order":17,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Suphi Nuri, “Suriye Felaketleri”, Âti, 29 Teşrinisani 1334 (29 Kasım 1918).","id":1189748,"journalCode":"","order":18,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Suphi Nuri, “Harb-i Umûmîde Gördüklerim: Mağlup Olur İken”, İleri, 23 Teşrinievvel\r\n1340-4 Teşrinisani 1340 (23 Ekim-4 Kasım 1924).","id":1189612,"journalCode":"","order":19,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"“Filistin Sahne-i Hezimeti”, Tasvir-i Efkâr, 4 Kânunuevvel 1334 (4 Aralık 1918).","id":1189719,"journalCode":"","order":20,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"“Mustafa Kemal Paşa ile Mülakat”, Minber, 17 Teşrinisani 1918 (17 Kasım \r\n1918).","id":1189648,"journalCode":"","order":21,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"“Mustafa Kemal Paşa’nın Beyanatı”, Zaman, 17 Teşrinisani 1918 (17 Kasım \r\n1918).","id":1189690,"journalCode":"","order":22,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"“Mustafa Kemal Paşa ile Mülakat”, Vakit, 18 Teşrinisani 1918 (18 Kasım 1918).","id":1189583,"journalCode":"","order":23,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"BirinciDünya\tBirinci Dünya Harbi’nde Filistin Cephesi ve Mustafa KemalPaşa,“Askeri Tarih Belgeleri Dergisi”, Yıl: 65, Sayı: 138, (Temmuz2016).","id":1189749,"journalCode":"","order":24,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Atatürkile 1982\tAtatürk ile ilgili Arşiv Belgeleri (1911-1921 Tarihleri ArasınaAit 106 Belge), T.C. Başbakanlık Osmanlı Arşivi Daire Başkanlığı Yayınları,Ankara.","id":1189613,"journalCode":"","order":25,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Atatürk’ün 2003\tAtatürk’ün Bütün Eserleri, Cilt: 2 (1915-1919), Kaynak Yayınları,İstanbul.","id":1189720,"journalCode":"","order":26,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Atilhan 2013\tCevat Rıfat Atilhan,Filistin-Suriye Cephesinde Kahramanlarve Hainler, Derin Tarih Kültür Yayınları,İstanbul.","id":1189649,"journalCode":"","order":27,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Bardakçı 1998\tMurat Bardakçı,Şahbaba: Osmanoğulları’nın SonHükümdarı\r\nVI. Mehmed Vahideddin’in Hayatı, Hatıraları ve ÖzelMektupları, Pan Yayıncılık, İstanbul.","id":1189691,"journalCode":"","order":28,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Bayur 1968\tYusuf Hikmet Bayur, “1918 Bırakışması Sırasındaki Tinsel Durum ve Mustafa Kemal’in İki Demeci”,Belleten, Cilt: XXXII, Sayı: 128, (Ekim), s.479-497.","id":1189584,"journalCode":"","order":29,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Belen 1967\tFahri Belen,Birinci Cihan Harbinde Türk Harbi: 1918 YılıHareketleri, Genelkurmay Basımevi,Ankara.","id":1189750,"journalCode":"","order":30,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Bowman-Manifold 1923Major-General Sir M. G. E. Bowman-Manifold,An Outline ofthe Egyptian and Palestine Campaigns, 1914 to 1918, The Institution of Royal Engineers, Chatham.","id":1189614,"journalCode":"","order":31,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Bozkurt 2011\t\tCelil Bozkurt,Eserleri ve Fikirleri ile Cevat Rifat Atilhan, (Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi), T.C. Marmara Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Enstitüsü,İstanbul.","id":1189721,"journalCode":"","order":32,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Bruce 2002\t\tAnthony Bruce,The Last Crusade: The Palestine Campaign inthe First World War, John Murray Publishers,London.","id":1189650,"journalCode":"","order":33,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Çay 2013\tMustafa Murat Çay,Cevat Rifat Atilhan -Askerî, Siyasî ve FikrîYönleriyle-, (Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi), T.C. Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü,Konya.","id":1189692,"journalCode":"","order":34,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"CevatRifat 2015\tMersinli Cemal Paşa’nın Yaveri Yüzbaşı Cevat Rifat Bey’inBirinci Dünya Savaşı ve Mütareke Dönemi Anıları, Hazırlayan: Celil Bozkurt, Gündoğan Yayınları,İstanbul.","id":1189585,"journalCode":"","order":35,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Ergin1991\t\tFeridun Ergin, “Mütareke Kabineleri”,Atatürk AraştırmaMerkezi Dergisi, Cilt: VII, Sayı: 21, (Temmuz), s.391-406.","id":1189751,"journalCode":"","order":36,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Falls ve Becke 1930 Captain Cyril Falls-Major A. F. Becke,Military Operations,Egypt \u0026 Palestine (History of the Great War Based on Official Documents), Part II:From June 1917 to the End of the War, His Majesty’s Stationery Office,London.","id":1189615,"journalCode":"","order":37,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Falls 1964\tCyril Falls,Armageddon, 1918 (The Final PalestinianCampaign of World War I,University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.","id":1189722,"journalCode":"","order":38,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Görgülü 2014\tİsmet Görgülü,On Yıllık Harbin Kadrosu (1912-1922):Balkan-Birinci Dünya ve İstiklal Harbi, Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayınları,Ankara.","id":1189651,"journalCode":"","order":39,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Grainger 2013\tJohn D. Grainger,The Battle For Syria, 1918-1920, The Boydell Press, Woodbridge,UK.","id":1189693,"journalCode":"","order":40,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Kemal 2013\tCemal Kemal, “Nablus Meydan Muharebesi’nde Mustafa Kemal”,Atatürk Yolu Dergisi, Cilt: 13, Sayı: 51 (Bahar), s. 617-651.","id":1189586,"journalCode":"","order":41,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Keogh 1954\t\tColonel E. G. Keogh,Suez to Aleppo, Wilke \u0026 Co. Ltd., Melbourne.","id":1189752,"journalCode":"","order":42,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Mirliva Sedat 2009 Mirliva Sedat,Yıldırım Ordularının Bozgunu: Filistin’e Veda, Yeditepe Yayınevi, İstanbul.","id":1189616,"journalCode":"","order":43,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Sanders2006\tLiman von Sanders,Türkiye’de Beş Sene, Yeditepe Yayınevi, İstanbul.","id":1189723,"journalCode":"","order":44,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Turan 1982\tŞerafettin Turan, “Mondros Mütarekesi Ertesinde M. Kemal’in Orduya, Siyasete ve İngilizlerin Tutumuna İlişkin Düşünceleri”,Belleten, Cilt: XLVI, Sayı: 182, (Nisan), s. 337- 347.","id":1189652,"journalCode":"","order":45,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"TürkHarbi 1986\tBirinci Dünya Harbi’nde Türk Harbi: Sina-Filistin Cephesi(IVncü Cilt 2nci Kısım), Yayına Hazırlayanlar: Kâmil Önalp- Hilmi Üstünsoy-Kâmuran Dengiz, Gnkur. Askeri Tarih ve Stratejik Etüt Başkanlığı Yayınları,Ankara.","id":1189694,"journalCode":"","order":46,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Ward 1927\t\tMajor C. H. Dudley Ward,History of the 53rd (Welsh)Division, 1914-1918, Western Mail Limited, Cardiff. (The Naval \u0026 Military Press,2004).\r\n \r\nWavell 1938\tColonel A. P. Wavell,The Palestine Campaigns, Constable and Co Limited, Third Edition (Sixth Impression),London.","id":1189587,"journalCode":"","order":47,"targetPublication":0,"year":""},{"authors":null,"context":"Woodward 2007\t\tDavid R. Woodward,Forgotten Soldiers of the First WorldWar, Tempus Publishing Limited, Stroud, Gloucestershire, UnitedKingdom.","id":1189753,"journalCode":"","order":48,"targetPublication":0,"year":""}],"retreat":false,"startPage":"481","startedDate":null,"subjects":[{"autoLabel":false,"fullName":"Sosyal \u003e Sosyal \u003e Tarih","id":185,"name":"Tarih","rootId":2,"rootName":"Sosyal"}],"viewCount":712}}],"max_score":12.1416445,"total":{"relation":"eq","value":1}},"timed_out":false,"took":3,"trdizinAddress":"https://search.trdizin.gov.tr/tr/yayin/detay/298011/NABLUS-MUHAREBESİ’NDE-MUSTAFA-KEMAL-PAŞA:-İTHAMLAR-VE-GERÇEKLER"}