Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)

AKÇAY, Aytaç; Çelik Gürbulak, Elif; Abay, Murat; Güngör, Güven

doi:10.55730/1300-0128.4248

Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)

Aytaç AKÇAY, (Ankara Üniversitesi, Veteriner Fakültesi, Biyoistatistik Anabilim Dalı, Ankara, Türkiye)

Elif ÇELİK, (Erciyes Üniversitesi, Veteriner Fakültesi, Biyometri Anabilim Dalı, Kayseri, Türkiye)

Güven GÜNGÖR, (Erciyes Üniversitesi, Veteriner Fakültesi, Biyometri Anabilim Dalı, Kayseri, Türkiye)

Murat ABAY (Erciyes Üniversitesi, Veteriner Fakültesi, Jinekoloji ve Doğum Hastalıkları Anabilim Dalı, Kayseri, Türkiye)

Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences

2 0

Yıl: 2022 Cilt: 46 Sayı: 5 Sayfa Aralığı: 734 - 747 Metin Dili: İngilizce DOI: 10.55730/1300-0128.4248 İndeks Tarihi: 28-12-2022

Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)

Öz:

Water buffalo milk, compared to cow’s milk, has a preferable composition in terms of health and nutritional value. Subclinical mastitis, one of the most important problems of the dairy industry, is as important of an issue in water buffaloes as in cows. In this study, it was aimed to evaluate the prevalence of subclinical mastitis in buffaloes by metaanalysis, and to calculate the pooled prevalence. For the metaanalysis of the prevalence of subclinical mastitis in buffaloes, a total of 382 publications 294 from Scopus, 31 from Medline Complete, and 57 from ScienceDirect were obtained as a result of the literature searches with the key words “Buffalo, Water buffalo, Nili Ravi, Bubalus bubalis, Asian buffalo, Jafarabadi, Italian Mediterranean buffalo, subclinical mastitis prevalence”. Five repeating studies were excluded. The study material is made up of 53 subclinical mastitis prevalence data derived from the 51 studies in total that were conducted between 1989 and 2020. In this study, 10,996 water buffaloes (water buffalo-based studies) and 44,372 udder quarters (udder quarter-based studies) were included in the metaanalysis. Additionally, a total of 3292 agent identification results from 38 prevalence data obtained from 14 studies were used for metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence by isolates. A high level of heterogeneity (I2(%) > 75%) was detected amongst both the water buffalo-based studies and the udder quarter-based studies that were included in the analyses. At the end of the study, subclinical mastitis pooled prevalence was calculated to be 0.38 (95% CI: 0.32–0.44) in water buffalo- based studies and 0.28 (95% CI: 0.23–0.34) in udder quarter-based studies. In 38 studies with agent identification, the pooled prevalence according to isolates for Staphylococcus spp., Streptococcus spp., Bacillus spp., coagulase-negative staphylococci (CNS), and Escherichia coli (E. coli) were respectively calculated as 0.36; 0.26; 0.03; 0.39, and 0.11. With this study, the inconsistencies in individual studies regarding the magnitude of the effect of the prevalence of subclinical mastitis in water buffaloes in the population were eliminated by metaanalysis, enabling us to make a stronger and more precise estimation.

Anahtar Kelime: Metaanalysis prevalence subclinical mastitis water buffalo

Belge Türü: Makale Makale Türü: Araştırma Makalesi Erişim Türü: Erişime Açık

1. Zhang Y, Colli L, Barker JSF. Asian water buffalo: domestication, history and genetics. Anim Genetics 2020; 51 (2): 177-191. doi:10.1111/age.12911
2. Yılmaz A, Kara MA. Dünyada ve Türkiye’de manda yetiştiriciliğinin durumu ve geleceği. Türkiye Tarımsal Araştırmalar Dergisi 2019; 6 (3): 356-363 (in Turkish). doi:10.19159/tutad.598629
3. Faostat. Crops and livestock products. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations 2019. Retrived on 22.06.2021.
4. Bülbül T. Energy and nutrient requirements of buffaloes. Kocatepe Veteriner Dergisi 2010; 3 (2): 55-64.
5. Rajput ZI, Hu SH, Arijo AG, Habib M, Khalid M. Comparative study of Anaplasma parasites in tick carrying buffaloes and cattle. Journal of Zhejiang University Science 2005; 6 (11): 1057-1062. doi:10.1631/jzus.2005.B1057
6. Dhakal IP. Normal somatic cell count and subclinical mastitis in Murrah buffaloes. Journal of Veterinary Medicine Series B: Infectious Diseases and Veterinary Public Health 2006; 53 (2): 81-86. doi:10.1111/j.1439-0450.2006.00918.x
7. Samad MA. A Systematic review of research findings on buffalo health and production published during the last six decades in Bangladesh. Journal of Veterinary Medical and One Health Research 2020; 2 (1): 1-62. doi:10.36111/jvmohr.2020.2(1).0016
8. Alaçam E, Tekeli T, Erganiş O, İzgi N. İnek ve mandalarda subklinik mastitislerin tanısı, etkenlerin izolasyonu ve bunlara karşı etkili antibiyotiklerin belirlenmesi. Selçuk Üniversitesi Veteriner Fakültesi Dergisi 1989; 5 (1): 91-101 (in Turkish).
9. Shahid M, Sabir N, Ahmed I, Khan RW, Irshad M et al. Diagnosis of subclinical mastitis in bovine using conventional methods and electronic detector. ARPN Journal of Agricultural and Biological Science 2011; 6 (11): 18-22.
10. Bulla TR, Rana YS, Sharma A, Beniwal BS. Prevalance of subclinical mastitis in Murrah buffaloes. Haryana Veterinarian 2006; 45: 53-56.
11. Ali L. Epidemiology of mastitis in dairy buffalo and cow in Tehsil Samundri of district Faisalabad. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Agriculture Faisalabad, Faisalabad, Pakistan, 2009.
12. Borenstein M, Higgins JPT. Meta-analysis and subgroups. Prevention science 2013; 14 (2): 134-143. doi:10.1007/s11121- 013-0377-7
13. Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 2021; 134: 178-189. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2021.03.001
14. Desta TT. Introduction of domestic buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) into Ethiopia would be feasible. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 2012; 27 (4): 305-313. doi:10.1017/ S1742170511000366
15. Aspilcueta-Borquis RR, Araujo Neto FR, Baldi F, Bignardi AB, Albuquerque LG et al. Genetic parameters for buffalo milk yield and milk quality traits using Bayesian inference. Journal of Dairy Science 2010; 93 (5): 2195-2201. doi:10.3168/jds.2009- 2621
16. Michelizzi VN, Dodson MV, Pan Z, Amaral MEJ, Michal JJ et al. Water buffalo genome science comes of age. International Journal of Biological Sciences 2010; 6 (4): 333-349. doi:10.7150/ ijbs.6.333
15. Tanamati F, Taylor JF, Behura SK et al. Short communication: Characterization of the milk protein expression profiles in dairy buffaloes with and without subclinical mastitis. Journal of Dairy Science 2020; 103 (3): 2677-2684. doi:10.3168/jds.2019- 16907
16. Abramson JH, Abramson ZH. Making Sense of Data: A Self- Instruction Manual on the Interpretation of Epidemiological Data. 3rd ed. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2001. pp. 274-275.
17. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. Practical Meta-Analysis. New York, USA. SAGE publications Inc; 2001.
18. Jhambh R, Dimri U, Gopalakrishnan A, Singh M, Chhabra R. Prevalence and risk factors of subclinical mastitis in buffalo at an organized dairy farm in western Haryana. Haryana Veterinarian 2017; 56 (2): 189-193.
19. Arfan HM, Ahmad T, Saqib M, Saleemi K, Hameed MR. Prevalence of mastitis in “recombinant bovine somatotropin (rbST)” treated herds of dairy buffaloes. Scholar’s Advances in Animal and Veterinary Research 2016; 3 (2): 68-78.
20. Hameed S, Arshad M, Ashraf M, Avais M, Shahid MA. Cross - sectional epidemiological studies on mastitis in cattle and buffaloes of Tehsil Burewala, Pakistan. The Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences 2012; 22 (3): 371-376.
21. Hussain A, Ahmad MUD, Mushtaq MH, Chaudhry M, Nisar M et al. Prevalence and sensitivity of staphylococcus aureus causing mastitis in buffaloes around Lahore, Pakistan. Buffalo Bulletin 2020; 39 (1): 9-16.
22. Chishty MA, Arshad M, Avais M, Hameed S, Ijaz M. Coss- sectional epidemiological studies on mastitis in cattle and buffaloes of Tehsil Gorja, Pakistan. Buffalo Bulletin 2007; 26 (2): 50-55.
23. Ali MA, Ahmad MD, Muhammad K, Anjum AA. Prevalence of subclinical mastitis in dairy buffaloes of Punjab, Pakistan. Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences 2011; 21 (3): 477-480.
24. Patel R, Kunjadia P, Koringa P, Joshi C, Kunjadiya A. Microbiological profiles in clinical and subclinical cases of mastitis in milking Jafarabadi buffalo. Research in Veterinary Science 2019; 125: 94-99. doi:10.1016/j.rvsc.2019.05.012
25. Baloch H, Rind R, Rind MR, Kumar V, Baloch N et al. Effect of Diverse Factors on the Frequency of Clinical and Subclinical Mastitis in Kundhi Buffaloes of Sindh, Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Zoology 2018; 50 (5): 1913-1920. doi:10.17582/ journal.pjz/2018.50.5.1619.1628
26. Chhabra R, Shrinet G, Yadav R, Talukdar SJ. Prevalence of subclinical mastitis in an organized buffalo dairy farm along with antibiogram. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences 2020; 9 (1): 1605-1612. doi:10.20546/ijcmas.2020.901.176
27. Kashyap DK, Giri DK, Dewangan G. Prevalence of sub clinical mastitis (Scm) in she buffaloes at surajpur district of chhattishgarh, india. Buffalo Bulletin 2019; 38 (2): 373-381.
28. Guha A, Guha R, Gera S. Comparison of somatic cell count, California mastitis test, chloride test and rennet coagulation time with bacterial culture examination to detect subclinical mastitis in riverine buffalo (Bubalus bubalis). African Journal of Agricultural Research 2012; 7 (41): 5578-5584. doi:10.5897/ AJAR12.922
29. Khan AZ, Muhammad G. Quarter-wise comparative prevalence of mastitis in buffaloes and crossbred cows. Pakistan Veterinary Journal 2005; 25 (1): 9-12.
30. Beheshti R, Eshratkhah B, Shayegh J, Giasi Ghalehkandi J, Dianat V et al. Prevalence and etiology of subclinical mastitis in Buffalo of the Tabriz region, Iran. Journal of American Science 2011; 7 (5): 642-645.
31. Memon MI, Mirbahar KB, Memon MR, Akhter N, Soomro SA et al. A study on the etiology of subclinical mastitis in buffaloes. Pakistan Journal of Agriculture, Agricultural Engineering and Veterinary Sciences 2001; 15 (1): 34-36.
32. Muhammad G, Naureen A, Asi MN, Saqib M, Fazal-ur- Rehman. Evaluation of a 3% surf solution (surf field mastitis test) for the diagnosis of subclinical bovine and bubaline mastitis. Tropical Animal Health and Production 2010; 42 (3): 457-464. doi:10.1007/s11250-009-9443-3
33. Khan AZ, Khan A, Hayat CS, Munir Z, Ayaz U. Prevalence of mastitis in buffaloes and antibiotics sensitivity profiles of isolates. Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences 2004; 2 (1): 73-75.
34. Sharma A, Sindhu N. Occurrence of clinical and subclinical mastitis in buffaloes in the State of Haryana (India). Italian Journal of Animal Science 2007; 6 (SUPPL. 2): 965-967. doi:10.4081/ijas.2007.s2.965
35. Sharma A, Chhabra R, Singh M, Charaya G. Prevalence, etiology and antibiogram of bacterial isolates recovered from mastitis of buffaloes. Buffalo Bulletin 2018; 37 (3): 313-320.
36. Özenç E, Vural MR, Şeker E, Uçar M. An evaluation of subclinical mastitis during lactation in anatolian buffaloes. Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences 2008; 32 (5): 359-368.
37. Ottalwar T, Roy M, Roy S, Ottalwar N. Prevalence of subclinical mastitis in buffaloes (Bubalus Bubalus) in Chhattisgarh, India. International Journal of Academic Scientific Research 2018; 8 (1): 9-16. doi:10.24247/ijasrfeb20182
38. Ahmed HF, Straubinger RK, Hegazy YM, Ibrahim S. Subclinical mastitis in dairy cattle and buffaloes among small holders in Egypt: Prevalence and evidence of virulence of escherichia coli causative agent. Tropical Biomedicine 2018; 35 (2): 321-329.
39. Sharif A, Ahmad T. Prevalence of severity of mastitis in buffaloes in district Faisalabad (Pakistan). Journal of Agriculture and Social Sciences 2007; 3 (1): 24-36.
40. Hardenberg F. Clinical and subclinical mastitis in dairy cattle and buffaloes in Bihar, India: Prevalence, major pathogens and risk factors. MSc, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden, 2016.
41. Bansal BK, Singh KB, Rohan R, Joshi D V, Nauriyal DC. Incidence of subclinical mastitis in some cow and buffalo herds in Punjab. Journal of Research, Punjab Agricultural University 1995; 32 (1): 79-81.
42. Krishnamoorthy P, Suresh KP, Saha S, Govindaraj G, Shome BR et al. Meta-analysis of prevalence of subclinical and clinical mastitis, major mastitis pathogens in dairy cattle in India. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences 2017; 6 (3): 1214-1234. doi:10.20546/ ijcmas.2017.603.141
43. Getaneh AM, Gebremedhin EZ. Meta-analysis of the prevalence of mastitis and associated risk factors in dairy cattle in Ethiopia. Tropical Animal Health and Production 2017; 49 (4): 697-705. doi:10.1007/s11250-017-1246-3
44. Krishnamoorthy P, Goudar AL, Suresh KP, Roy P. Global and countrywide prevalence of subclinical and clinical mastitis in dairy cattle and buffaloes by systematic review and meta- analysis. Research in Veterinary Science 2021; 136: 561-586. doi:10.1016/j.rvsc.2021.04.021.

APA	AKÇAY A, Çelik Gürbulak E, Güngör G, Abay M (2022). Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). , 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
Chicago	AKÇAY Aytaç,Çelik Gürbulak Elif,Güngör Güven,Abay Murat Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). (2022): 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
MLA	AKÇAY Aytaç,Çelik Gürbulak Elif,Güngör Güven,Abay Murat Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). , 2022, ss.734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
AMA	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). . 2022; 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
Vancouver	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). . 2022; 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
IEEE	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M "Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)." , ss.734 - 747, 2022. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
ISNAD	AKÇAY, Aytaç vd. "Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)". (2022), 734-747. https://doi.org/10.55730/1300-0128.4248

APA	AKÇAY A, Çelik Gürbulak E, Güngör G, Abay M (2022). Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, 46(5), 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
Chicago	AKÇAY Aytaç,Çelik Gürbulak Elif,Güngör Güven,Abay Murat Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences 46, no.5 (2022): 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
MLA	AKÇAY Aytaç,Çelik Gürbulak Elif,Güngör Güven,Abay Murat Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, vol.46, no.5, 2022, ss.734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
AMA	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences. 2022; 46(5): 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
Vancouver	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis). Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences. 2022; 46(5): 734 - 747. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
IEEE	AKÇAY A,Çelik Gürbulak E,Güngör G,Abay M "Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)." Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, 46, ss.734 - 747, 2022. 10.55730/1300-0128.4248
ISNAD	AKÇAY, Aytaç vd. "Metaanalysis of subclinical mastitis prevalence in water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis)". Turkish Journal of Veterinary and Animal Sciences 46/5 (2022), 734-747. https://doi.org/10.55730/1300-0128.4248