Yıl: 2021 Cilt: 32 Sayı: 1 Sayfa Aralığı: 1 - 10 Metin Dili: İngilizce DOI: 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562 İndeks Tarihi: 28-05-2022

What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Öz:
Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) is technically demanding and carries significant risks. It is performed by gastrointestinal and surgical endoscopists. There is no consensus on the minimum number of ERCPs required during training. This study was conducted to analyze the minimum number of clinical ERCPs that a trainee needs to perform to achieve competency. PubMed, Ovid-Embase, and the Cochrane library were searched systematically for prospective and retrospective studies reporting on trainees’ ERCP performance. Mete-analysis was conducted to analyze the success rate of cannulation, other basic techniques, and adverse event rate, using the random-effect model with Review Manager 5.3. Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria, with 149 trainees performing a total of 18 794 ERCP procedures. The pooled cannulation success rate was 85.7% (95% CI: 78.1%-91.0%) at completion of training. The cannulation success rate was 76.5% (95% CI: 69.2%-82.5%) when the trainees had completed 180 ERCPs, which increased to 81.8% (95% CI: 69.8%-90.6%) after 200 ERCP procedures. Adverse events and post-ERCP pancreatitis rates were 4.7% (95% CI: 2.9%-9.1%) and 2.0% (0.9%-3.9%), respectively. Achieving a cannulation success rate of >90% was considered a quality indicator for ERCP training by most societal guidelines. However, our retrospective analysis indicated that trainees only attained a pooled cannulation success rate of only 81.8% after 200 procedures. Therefore, the minimum number of ERCPs required to achieve competency during training may need to be redefined to meet the basic requirement.
Anahtar Kelime:

Belge Türü: Makale Makale Türü: Derleme Erişim Türü: Erişime Açık
  • 1. Carr-Locke DL. Overview of the role of ERCP in the management of diseases of the biliary tract and the pancreas. Gastrointest Endosc. 2002;56(6)(Suppl):S157-S160. [CrossRef]
  • 2. Jowell PS, Baillie J, Branch MS, Affronti J, Browning CL, Bute BP. Quantitative assessment of procedural competence. A prospective study of training in endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography. Ann Intern Med. 1996;125(12):983-989. [CrossRef]
  • 3. Sivak MV. Trained in ERCP. Gastrointest Endosc. 2003;58(3):412- 414. [CrossRef]
  • 4. Leung J, Foster E. How do we ensure that trainees learn to perform biliary sphincterotomy safely, appropriately, and effectively? Curr Gastroenterol Rep. 2008;10(2):163-168. [CrossRef]
  • 5. Chutkan RK, Ahmad AS, Cohen J, et al. ERCP core curriculum. Gastrointest Endosc. 2006;63(3):361-376. [CrossRef]
  • 6. Committee ASOP, Faulx AL, Lightdale JR, et al. Guidelines for privileging, credentialing, and proctoring to perform GI endoscopy. Gastrointest Endosc. 2017;85(2):273-281. [CrossRef]
  • 7. Cockeram A. Canadian Association of Gastroenterology Practice Guideline for clinical competence in diagnostic and therapeutic endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography. Can J Gastroenterol. 1997;11(6):535-538. [CrossRef]
  • 8. Shahidi N, Ou G, Telford J, Enns R. When trainees reach competency in performing ERCP: a systematic review. Gastrointest Endosc. 2015;81(6):1337-1342. [CrossRef]
  • 9. Schutz SM, Abbott RM. Grading ERCPs by degree of difficulty: a new concept to produce more meaningful outcome data. Gastrointest Endosc. 2000;51(5):535-539. [CrossRef]
  • 10. Watkins JL, Etzkorn KP, Wiley TE, Deguzman L, Harig JM. Assessment of technical competence during ERCP training. Gastrointest Endosc. 1996;44(4):411-415. [CrossRef]
  • 11. Schlup MM, Williams SM, Barbezat GO. ERCP: a review of technical competency and workload in a small unit. Gastrointest Endosc. 1997;46(1):48-52. [CrossRef]
  • 12. Biau DJ, Williams SM, Schlup MM, Nizard RS, Porcher R. Quantitative and individualized assessment of the learning curve using LCCUSUM. Br J Surg. 2008;95(7):925-929. [CrossRef]
  • 13. Kowalski T, Kanchana T, Pungpapong S. Perceptions of gastroenterology fellows Regarding ERCP competency and training. Gastrointest Endosc. 2003;58(3):345-349. [CrossRef]
  • 14. Vitale GC, Zavaleta CM, Vitale DS, Binford JC, Tran TC, Larson GM. Training surgeons in endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography. Surg Endosc. 2006;20(1):149-152. [CrossRef]
  • 15. Verma D, Gostout CJ, Petersen BT, Levy MJ, Baron TH, Adler DG. Establishing a true assessment of endoscopic competence in ERCP during training and beyond: a single-operator learning curve for deep biliary cannulation in patients with native papillary anatomy. Gastrointest Endosc. 2007;65(3):394-400. [CrossRef]
  • 16. Waller HM, Connor SJ. Cumulative sum (Cusum) analysis provides an objective measure of competency during training in endoscopic retrograde cholangio-pancreatography (ERCP). HPB. 2009;11(7):565- 569. [CrossRef]
  • 17. Ekkelenkamp VE, Koch AD, Rauws EAJ, Borsboom GJJM, de Man RA, Kuipers EJ. Competence development in ERCP: the learning curve of novice trainees. Endoscopy. 2014;46(11):949-955. [CrossRef]
  • 18. Kwek BE, Ang TL, Teo EK, Fock KM. Making ERCP training safe: a protocol-based strategy to minimize complications during selective biliary cannulation. J Interv Gastroenterol. 2012;2(2):66-69. [CrossRef]
  • 19. Pan Y, Zhao L, Leung J, et al. Appropriate time for selective biliary cannulation by trainees during ERCP - a randomized trial. Endoscopy. 2015;47(8):688-695. [CrossRef]
  • 20. Frost JW, Kurup A, Shetty S, Fisher N. Does the presence of a trainee compromise success of biliary cannulation at ERCP? Endosc Int Open. 2017;5(7):E559-E562. [CrossRef]
  • 21. Wani S, Hall M, Wang AY, et al. Variation in learning curves and competence for ERCP among advanced endoscopy trainees by using cumulative sum analysis. Gastrointest Endosc. 2016;83(4):711.e11- 719.e11. [CrossRef]
  • 22. Mccune WS, Shorb PE, Moscovitz H. Endoscopic cannulation of the ampulla of Vater: a preliminary report. Ann Surg. 1968;167(5):752- 756. [CrossRef]
  • 23. Barker AE. Training the gastroenterologist of the future: the gastroenterology core curriculum. The Gastroenterology Leadership Council. Gastroenterology. 1996;110(4):1266-1300. [CrossRef]
  • 24. American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases; American College of Gastroenterology; AGA Institute; American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy. A journey toward excellence: training future gastroenterologists - the gastroenterology core curriculum, third edition. Am J Gastroenterol. 2007;102:921-927.
  • 25. Voiosu T, Bengus A, Voiosu A, et al. Trainee caseload correlates with ERCP success rates but not with procedure-related complications: results from a prospective study (the QUASIE cohort). Endosc Int Open. 2016;4(4):E409-E414. [CrossRef]
  • 26. Wani S, Han S, Simon V, et al. Setting minimum standards for training in EUS and ERCP: results from a prospective multicenter study evaluating learning curves and competence among advanced endoscopy trainees. Gastrointest Endosc. 2019;89(6):1160.e9-1168.e9. [CrossRef]
  • 27. Wani S, Keswani R, Hall M, et al. A prospective multicenter study evaluating learning curves and competence in endoscopic ultrasound and endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography among advanced endoscopy trainees: the rapid assessment of trainee endoscopy skills study. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017;15(11):1758. e11-1767.e11. [CrossRef]
  • 28. Freeman ML. Toward improving outcomes of ERCP. Gastrointest Endosc. 1998;48(1):96-102. [CrossRef]
  • 29. Kapral C, Duller C, Wewalka F, Kerstan E, Vogel W, Schreiber F. Case volume and outcome of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography: results of a nationwide Austrian benchmarking project. Endoscopy. 2008;40(8):625-630. [CrossRef]
  • 30. Wani S, Keswani RN, Elta GH, et al. 774 perceptions of training among program directors and trainees in complex endosopic procedures (CEPs): a nationwide survey of US ACGME accredited gastroenterology training programs. Gastroenterology. 2015;148:S-150.
  • 31. Liao WC, Leung JW, Wang HP, et al. Coached practice using ERCP mechanical simulator improves trainees’ ERCP performance: a randomized controlled trial. Endoscopy. 2013;45(10):799-805. [CrossRef]
  • 32. Matthes K, Cohen J. The Neo-Papilla: a new modification of porcine ex vivo simulators for ERCP training (with videos). Gastrointest Endosc. 2006;64(4):570-576. [CrossRef]
  • 33. Leung JW, Lee W, Wilson R, Lim BS, Leung FW. Comparison of accessory performance using a novel ERCP mechanical simulator. Endoscopy. 2008;40(12):983-988. [CrossRef]
APA Fu W, LEUNG J, Wang Y, CHUANG T, LİAO W, Meng W, ZHOU W, Lİ X (2021). What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. , 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
Chicago Fu Wenkang,LEUNG Joseph,Wang Yudong,CHUANG Tang-Wei,LİAO Wei-Chih,Meng Wenbo,ZHOU Wence,Lİ Xun What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. (2021): 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
MLA Fu Wenkang,LEUNG Joseph,Wang Yudong,CHUANG Tang-Wei,LİAO Wei-Chih,Meng Wenbo,ZHOU Wence,Lİ Xun What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. , 2021, ss.1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
AMA Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. . 2021; 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
Vancouver Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. . 2021; 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
IEEE Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X "What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis." , ss.1 - 10, 2021. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
ISNAD Fu, Wenkang vd. "What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis". (2021), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
APA Fu W, LEUNG J, Wang Y, CHUANG T, LİAO W, Meng W, ZHOU W, Lİ X (2021). What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology, 32(1), 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
Chicago Fu Wenkang,LEUNG Joseph,Wang Yudong,CHUANG Tang-Wei,LİAO Wei-Chih,Meng Wenbo,ZHOU Wence,Lİ Xun What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology 32, no.1 (2021): 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
MLA Fu Wenkang,LEUNG Joseph,Wang Yudong,CHUANG Tang-Wei,LİAO Wei-Chih,Meng Wenbo,ZHOU Wence,Lİ Xun What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology, vol.32, no.1, 2021, ss.1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
AMA Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology. 2021; 32(1): 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
Vancouver Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology. 2021; 32(1): 1 - 10. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
IEEE Fu W,LEUNG J,Wang Y,CHUANG T,LİAO W,Meng W,ZHOU W,Lİ X "What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis." Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology, 32, ss.1 - 10, 2021. 10.5152/tjg.2020.19562
ISNAD Fu, Wenkang vd. "What Would Be the Appropriate Number of Clinical ERCP Cases for Trainees to Acquire Basic Competence? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis". Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology 32/1 (2021), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.5152/tjg.2020.19562